『大鎮反』觀後感

最近一直在pps上看影片..

因為有點懶得整理下禮拜的東西…

但看來看去

我還真有點看膩了偶像劇…

每部沒看過但被我在pps點到的偶像劇 我每部都看個不到一集就不想再看了…

然後我就在在pps上的"內地劇場"亂點 就給我亂點到了一部奇妙的戲~

叫作「熱愛」 原名叫做「大鎮反」

我才看了第一集 就一直這樣看下去看到完了…

為啥我說它是部奇妙的戲

他的時空背景應該是1920至1950時….

國共內戰完 老國民黨敗了 蔣中正徹退到台灣之後 共產黨開始大躍進 除四害的那個年代…

不過有趣的是

從以前到現在 我所看過的戲或是連續劇 如果時空背景是在那個年代 ~

我看到的思維大致都是從台灣人、從老國民黨的角度出發~

但這部「大鎮反」不是,這部是從那時"共產黨"的基層角度出發~

這讓從以前就很喜歡歷史的我有了想一探究竟的心態…

喔我剛都忘了說~

演這部戲的男主角是蘇有朋 女主角是韓雪

男主角是給個台灣人來演 這也是我覺得奇妙的點之二

因為當我完完整整看完這部戲之後

我想它絕對不可能會在台灣播

這部戲不僅有兩岸的敏感議題 說不定還會引起台灣的藍綠政治鬥爭…

但我必須承認 它是好看的…

看完真的會讓人深思

我覺得我們必須要了解

我們以前讀的有關台灣的歷史 “可能"都有偏向自己這邊有以偏概全的寫法…

不過 說不定這部戲說的背景敘述也可能是假的 我不知道 我也無從考證..

但他演得真的太真實了~

那時的中國

有許許多多窮人 而不能否認 他們是佔大多數的…

他們連吃飽都有問題 所以他們更不可能上過學、讀過書、甚至連識字都不會….

有一天 如果你對那些人說我們要把資產階級(就是所謂的有錢人)的錢都拿出來平均分攤給大家~

所有人一視同仁 沒有所謂的階級問題 大家都是自己的主人!!

加上一些所謂讀過書可以曉以大義的知識份子推波助瀾…..

你想 那些沒讀過書的聽到自己有錢可領有飯可吃 誰不都是舉雙手讚成嗎?

他們誰會理所謂的"民主"真諦…. 他們只要當下有飯可吃就好了….

可想而知 那時老國民黨會敗不是沒有原因的…

加上當時又有日本軍的侵襲~

那時的老蔣起初只有勦共 卻沒有抗日~

導致生活本來就已經很困苦的他們又矇上一層隨時都會被國民黨當成共產黨被抓去槍斃的陰影…

那時的人民只會認為在老蔣國民黨的領導之下~

有錢的愈來愈有錢 窮的就愈來愈窮…

加上又沒念過什麼書 有人煽動 他們就有可能會盲從~

都快餓死了 誰還會想了解真正所謂的"民主"、真正的"自由經濟"是什麼…

唉..其實說起來也真複雜….

算了不說這些老舊歷史了…

真是愈寫愈沉重….

只能說 所謂的"歷史"並不是任何一個人就可以造就出來的…

即使即便你認為這個歷史是錯誤的~

他也不會是某一個人的錯…這是一個大環境、一個趨勢所推砌出來的!!!

這部戲其實真的很好看

不僅有內容 而且也很感人

其實一直以來我都覺得蘇有朋應該是演那種白臉小生或是斯文的瓊瑤男主角那一型的~

結果他在這部完全顛覆了..

他這部應該是已經沒偶像形象可言了吧..

他演得真的很好!!

尤其是變成精神病患那一段~

讓我覺得我看到的真的是個瘋子在我眼前…

看到他的脖子、頭還有嘴角一直在抽蓄 害我就會不自覺的頭也想動 噗噗

還有當他跟寒秋(女主角韓雪戲裡的名字)分開六年後的那種滄桑~

讓我覺得他的每一句話 每個表情…都好像有幾百句的台詞沒講完….

只可惜他的配音實在是讓我聽得很刺耳…

這麼真實的一部戲..

為什麼就不用演員原來的聲音= =

還有 其實女主角韓雪也演得很好~

其實我在看這部之前 我根本不知道韓雪是誰XD

她可以把痛苦及希望、深愛演進同一個表情裡…

尤其是她演哭戲 眼淚可以說根本是水龍頭~

真的好厲害!!!!

而且她真的很漂亮耶~~~

哈哈

喔對了

這部戲還有一項最讓我詬病的地方就是它的後製及3D….

我的媽阿!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

它的後製也做太爛了吧= =

那玻璃碎得也太假 我用AE作都做得都比他還真….

還有 某些片段的背景合成也太爛了吧

竟然連景深都沒有…

就像演員是在壁紙前演得一樣…

還有冰湖破洞的那個3D…真的..我完全無法接受><!!!!

後製爛到像是十幾年前做得那種…

不知道pps上的是不是完整版~

我真的有點懷疑是那種山寨未完成的外流版…….

不過

撇開我的這些看影片的"職業病"~

「大鎮反」的劇情真的是好看的~演員也演得很好!!!!

我誠心推薦可以去看看喔^^


(其實我有點懷疑這張照片會不會也是山寨版XD)

 

961 comments to “『大鎮反』觀後感”

You can leave a reply or Trackback this post.
  1. 哈哈 找到一個跟我一樣想法的人了….台灣人看這部戲 確實有很妙的感覺 :p
    當初 我是衝蘇有朋去看這戲的 只是 看完後 我第一個想法跟你一樣 這種戲我看永遠都不可能在台灣播…..第二個想法 蘇明濤純真的讓人心疼啊 第三個想法 那個年代的人對國對黨真的很純也很蠢 我發覺明濤對小圓說得每句話都很有道理 其中有一句話我印象深刻"沒有文化就分不清是非" 就因為那個年代 教育不普及 所以由得那些高官高知識份子力用人性的弱點 顛倒黑白 煽動人心 造成群眾的對立 人心惶惶……
    呵 可悲的是 現在民眾的教育是普及的 但還是容易被一些政客煽動 造成族群的對立 眼中沒有和平 沒有是非 只有藍綠 依舊是人心惶惶 充滿憤恨…..唉…..
    版主回覆:(08/15/2009 03:29:26 PM)
    嗯嗯嗯!!
    你說得很對!!!!
    不過你說的"現在民眾的教育是普及的 但還是容易被一些政客煽動 造成族群的對立等…."
    這句話讓我突然想到明濤跟小圓說的"唯心主義"論~
    "用主觀的結論來解釋客觀的事實"
    現在的人大多都知道主觀的認定往往都會影響客觀的事實~~
    但要自己真的辦到 其實很難…
    因為這樣就違背了自己心理原來的"認定"~
    其實我覺得現在的人應該不能算是被政客煽動…
    而是這些人的立場及政治色彩 是早在心裡就已根深蒂固的"認定"..
    然後當他看到電視上的那些政客所遊說的~
    跟他在心裡就根深蒂固的立場觀念剛好不謀而合時…
    就會有所謂的盲從出現!!甚至會出現更激烈的政治鬥爭行為…
    唉..其實說起來真的很可悲…
    但這又有甚麼辦法? 這就是人性阿…
    哈哈 看一部片能得到這麼多的啟發~
    還真是少見阿….
    噗噗

  2. 其實我覺得現在的人應該不能算是被政客煽動…
    而是這些人的立場及政治色彩 是早在心裡就已根深蒂固的"認定"..
    然後當他看到電視上的那些政客所遊說的~
    跟他在心裡就根深蒂固的立場觀念剛好不謀而合時…
    就會有所謂的盲從出現!!甚至會出現更激烈的政治鬥爭行為…
    哇 我崇拜你 你說得更有道理….就是這樣 有人生命中曾矇上白色恐怖的陰影 所以 更容易陷入政客鬥爭之中 不是因為他們愛某個黨或人 只因他們恨某個黨或人….. 🙁
    版主回覆:(08/16/2009 02:44:15 PM)

    不用崇拜我啦~
    我會害羞XD
    我也只是把我想到得說出來而已^^
    謝謝你的抬舉阿
    呵呵

  3. Very good website you have here but I was wanting to know
    if you knew of any forums that cover the same topics discussed here?
    I’d really love to be a part of group where I can get feedback from other knowledgeable people that share the same interest.
    If you have any recommendations, please let me know. Appreciate it!

  4. Some First Class stamps https://terp.umd.edu/?s=Baikal%20Online%20Pharmacy%20%E2%AD%90%20www.Pills2Sale.com%20%E2%AD%90%20Buy%20Celexa%20Baikal-pharmacy%20Com%20-%20Buy%20Celexa%20Baikal-pharmacy buy celexa baikal-pharmacy
    White said that if the United States pursues a broader agreement to end the fighting, Washington could place pressure on the rebels to tamp down military operations. “That shows we could get sucked into the business of pressuring the rebels to do less in the hopes of getting a negotiated settlement," he said.

  5. What sort of work do you do? https://orpheogroup.com/stmap_21wizxfu.html?cialis.furazolidone.parlodel.meclizine risperdal consta 25 mg equivalent All the other narcissistic nonsense aside, A-Rod loved to talk about all things baseball, as they applied to the Yankees and teams around the league as well. Similarly, he watches game around the league at home, and couldn’t fathom it to find out years ago that Derek Jeter doesn’t have the MLB package in his house.

  6. I can’t stand football https://www.goodworkint.com/stmap_21snbbax.html?misoprostol.zyvox.levitra levothyroxine sodium cost Carmick picks the beer labels based upon a mix of local and regional craft beers he likes to drink, but also to raise awareness of some of the harder to get brews. “I really wanted to highlight local craft beers, but I realize that not too many people outside of Massachusetts  have even heard of beers like Pretty Things or Jack’s Abby. Hell, we can’t even get my favorite beer, Edmund Fitzgerald here in Boston!"

  7. How would you like the money? https://altreluci.com/stmap_24wriwom.html?tylenol.quetiapine.cialis.escitalopram ibuprofen 200 tablet uses in hindi Additionally, the PSAT is a tool many colleges and universities use to identify students they think may make a good addition to their student body and who many be deserving of scholarships. These scores are a way for colleges to be more selective in their recruitment process, and having schools express interest in you and recruit you to apply can also increase confidence. 

  8. There’s a three month trial period https://pjreporters.com/stmap_18vfkjbs.html?montelukast.cialis.tadagra.silymarin flucloxacillin emc Chris Mason, a professor of regenerative medicine at University College London, said he had no doubt that being able to reprogram cells in the body to different cell types would be useful in producing future therapies capable of transforming patients’ lives, but said there were many more years of research ahead before that would be possible.

  9. How many days will it take for the cheque to clear? https://www.burleighbears.com.au/stmap_37iydmeb.html?purim.levitra.isosorbide.gasex-sr one care pharmacy According to the World Health Organization, obsessive-compulsive disorder, or OCD, is one of the 10 leading causes of disability in the developed world. “OCD is characterized by recurrent disturbing, distressing or intrusive thoughts called obsessions, or ritualized behaviors or mental acts, called compulsions,” says Grice. “Individuals with OCD usually try to actively dismiss or neutralize an obsession by performing a compulsion or avoiding situations that trigger these thoughts, but the compulsion is a short-term fix that ends up feeding the OCD cycle.”

  10. Sorry, you must have the wrong number https://www.burleighbears.com.au/stmap_18jbbvts.html?filagra.viagra.suminat.femara concord pharmacy briarwood Those concerns eased somewhat on Tuesday when Apple reportedstronger-than-expected iPhone sales, even if demand was stokedby aggressively discounted older models. The California-basedcompany still reported a fall in quarterly profit of 22 percentas its margins slipped in the absence of new products.

  11. this post is fantastic https://www.ebbersgroenprojecten.nl/stmap_37iydmeb.html?viagra.mesylate.macrobid ciprofloxacino 500 gonorrea “With the clock ticking on the agency’s trust fund, some in Congress refuse to acknowledge the disability programs are broken and are in dire need of significant oversight," Oklahoma Sen. Tom Coburn, a doctor and the top Republican on the committee, said in prepared remarks. “While lawyers, doctors were getting rich by exploiting a broken program, the real victims were the claimants and the American taxpayer."

  12. I’d like to send this parcel to https://www.system32solutions.com.mx/stmap_24pkcjjq.html?cialis.ethionamide.tegopen.erectalis super avana kaina Baseball’s collective bargaining agreement allowed Rodriguez to take the field in Chicago for his first big-league game since his January hip surgery. His discipline officially begins Thursday, when the players’ union will file a grievance, staying the suspension while an arbitration process commences.

  13. Is there ? https://www.burleighbears.com.au/stmap_37iydmeb.html?tinidazole.elimite.cialis.cystone ivermectina fica no corpo quanto tempo European stocks are seen opening steady, consolidating asharp upward move over the last three weeks, with traderslooking to closely watched German ZEW sentiment index fordirection. The index is seen rising to 39.6, which wouldindicate a third straight month of growing confidence in theeuro zone’s biggest economy.

  14. I’m sorry, I didn’t catch your name https://www.ebbersgroenprojecten.nl/stmap_37iydmeb.html?topiramate.levitra.acivir.diskus panadol en gotas Capitol Hill has stopped short of calling for this deal to be blocked, but is worrying that old sore – security – to ensure it does not steam right through either. Senators have suggested that Shaunghui will steal American intellectual property, never mind that pork farming techniques are already pretty standardised the world over. They also questioned the implications the deal might have for the safety of food in America’s supply chain, one which they hailed as “the safest, most efficient and reliable” in the world.

  15. Three years http://adamdesautels.com/stmap_18jbbvts.html?azithromycin.suprax.viagra fluticasone propionate mims malaysia Broadchurch (which Fox has already planned an American adaption of) isn’t melodramatic–if anything, it has a stylized, moody, sea-breeze chill–but it leaves its heart exposed all the same. It probably benefits from the fact that it doesn’t have to play out its mystery for 13 or 22 episodes–or beyond, to another season. But what’s great about Broadchurch is not that, in the end, it lets you know everything. It’s that it makes you feel everything.

  16. Could you tell me my balance, please? https://www.lynnesilver.com/stmap_37iydmeb.html?malegra.imipramine.viagra depo medrol compresse The Rangers gave up two top quality prospects for Garza in third baseman Mike Olt and righthander C.J. Edwards, but still have plenty of depth in their system to fill their outfield need. The White Sox are hoping to get a bidding war going for Rios between the Rangers and Pittsburgh Pirates, who are also looking for a corner outfielder. As for the Orioles, they gave up one of their better prospects, lefthanded-hitting third baseman Nick Delmonico, for Brewers closer Francisco Rodriguez, but it was a deal they had to make. Their bullpen is among the major league leaders with 17 blown saves, six of them by closer Jim Johnson. Unfortunately, their rotation is in desperate need of a No. 1 or 2 starter. Jason Hammel was supposed to be that guy but he’s regressed to a 5.20 ERA this year while the Oriole pitchers have yielded the third-most homers in the majors.

  17. I’m on holiday https://endydaniyanto.net/stmap_18vfkjbs.html?shallaki.viagra.griseofulvin.gemfibrozil cefpodoxime indications in pediatrics Andy Murray once described bananas as “a pathetic fruit", but he munched several in beating Roger Federer today. “I’ve always had them because of what they have in them," he said. “I’m still not a fan." That was clear in Murray’s autobiography. “They don’t look great," he wrote. “They’re not straight. I don’t like the black bit at the bottom. I’m more a peaches and plums sort."

  18. A Second Class stamp https://www.ebbersgroenprojecten.nl/stmap_18jbbvts.html?ursodiol.levitra.motrin dbi metformina prospecto European countries invest in China ,a lot of investment is through joint ventures.They want technological knowledge and when they get it will they dump the European companies now partners seeing them as competition?America fears Chinese companies buying their firms not to invest just to get USA patents.The US has banned Samsung imports on patent disputes so the Chinese know their importance.

  19. Whereabouts are you from? https://www.lynnesilver.com/stmap_24pkcjjq.html?maxaquin.klaricid.cialis para q sirve gabapentin Chubu Electric last month broke an unwritten rule among utilities not to stray onto each others’ turf by buying control of Diamond Power Corp, a Tokyo-based independent electricity supplier. Chubu Electric, Mitsubishi Corp, the seller of the Diamond Power stake, and Nippon Paper Industries Co will also build a coal-fired power station near Tokyo to supply Diamond Power.

  20. I’m doing a phd in chemistry https://www.ebbersgroenprojecten.nl/stmap_18jbbvts.html?amoxapine.viagra.cytotec sleepwell mattress store chennai tamil nadu But on Thursday, the dollar index, which tracks thegreenback against a basket of major currencies, gained 1.1percent to 82.341. Though still not far from a six-weeklow touched on Wednesday after the Fed’s policy announcement,the dollar jumped as investors took the data as a sign of steadyimprovement in the U.S. economy.

  21. About a year http://josefinearenius.se/stmap_38qnpxzx.html?sinemet.viagra.advair.losartan acyclovir for warts on face Timothy Church, a physician and director of preventive medicine research at the Pennington Biomedical Research Center in Baton Rouge, says the latest findings make “sense to me when you consider that exercise strengthens all parts of the human machine — the heart, the liver, the brain, the blood vessels, the muscles."

  22. I’m interested in https://edgarsyouthprog.org/stmap_72yxfzej.html?progesterone.arava.eurax.levitra ursodiol 300 mg para que sirve en el embarazo For 2011's Golden Globes, Brittany wore a floaty Grecian style dress by high street favourite French Connection. Thanks to their high end details and original designs, French Connection has often been favoured for the red carpet by celebrities such as Mollie King, Zara Martin, Taylor Swift and Pippa Middleton.

  23. I’m retired https://asianwhiteskin.com/stmap_38ilarsy.html?benoquin.nymphomax.alli.cialis gotas de ciprofloxacino para ojos Not that the Giants have much margin for error. They’ve limped through the opening quarter of this season, but Rolle insisted that this week’s showdown with the Eagles is “for new beginnings” and added that “this is a 12-game season for us at this point” and “nothing that has taken place matters.”

  24. I’ve got a part-time job https://asianwhiteskin.com/stmap_72yxfzej.html?cialis.micronase.trandate khasiat etaflox ciprofloxacin In fairness, the situation we find ourselves in developed over several years and through a dispiriting series of missteps. It is a collage of the decisions and policies of both the last and current administrations, as well as a pervasive domestic undercurrent of self-doubt. Between the predilection for unilateralism of the second Bush administration, and the seeming overreaction to and withdrawal from active commitments in President Obama’s, we have managed to damage our brand in both extremes.

  25. I’d like to send this parcel to https://saaralfoods.com/stmap_72yxfzej.html?cialis.tizanidine.vicerex kamagra oral jelly jak stosowa There are some distinct differences, as well. Instead of industrial-grade magnesium alloy, the Satellite models feature brushed aluminum. The chassis may be fairly slim, but it’s isn’t the same ultra-thin tapered design of the Kirabook. And perhaps the biggest difference is that while the Satellite models do have touch-screen options available, the resolution is a pedestrian 1,366 by 768, not even attempting to match the Kirabook’s ultra-high-resolution display. That said, the aluminum lid and palmrest is luxurious compared to the all plastic designs seen on past Satellite models, and the metal construction is very sturdy.

  26. Wonderfull great site https://techflashes.com/stmap_38qnpxzx.html?felodipine.viagra.hyzaar can you take tylenol and mobic together Investment banks have a long history of employing thechildren of China’s politically connected. While close ties totop government officials is a boon to any banking franchiseacross the world, it’s especially beneficial in China, whererelationships and personal connections play a critical role inbusiness decisions.

  27. I do some voluntary work https://frantiskaoliver.com/stmap_72xsvvgd.html?levitra.topiramate.asendin.vaseretic ciprofloxacina ampolla precio colombia Unsurprisingly, given the Beats’ own celebration of brotherhood, the men are much more successful. DeHaan is extraordinarily well-cast, not only for his golden boy magnetism but his natural ease with a series of florid speeches. Hall makes Kammerer, an apparently irredeemable character in real life, surprisingly sympathetic. And Foster is nearly unrecognizable in his amusingly dry take on Burroughs.

  28. I work with computers https://appes.com.br/v2/stmap_72pkzsdq.html?metronidazole.cialis.azelastine bactrim dosis itu It makes for great intrigue anyway in a series that became personal in Game 3, as Carlos Beltran objected publicly to Puig’s fist-pumping and such, while Wainwright accused Gonzalez of chirping at him from third base. All in all, the Cardinals essentially seemed to be telling the Dodgers to grow up, and as such battle lines were drawn.

  29. Do you need a work permit? http://www.surfinglabenne.com/stmap_15vkkger.html?cytotec.flovent.cialis how to order abilify maintena Bottom line: Short of installing its own cameras in every ballpark, there’s no way for MLB to guarantee true video independence. So for those worried about replay review taking the human element out of the game, chill. The cats working the camera have a pulse. So do the producers and directors who control what we see.

  30. Please call back later https://www.amecco.org.ar/wp/stmap_38ddgxdq.html?cialis.cenforce.asendin buy tadalis sx baikal-pharmacy com The handheld biosensor was developed by researchers at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. A series of lenses and filters in the cradle mirror those found in larger, more expensive laboratory devices. Together, the cradle and app transform a smartphone into a tool that can detect toxins and bacteria, spot water contamination and identify allergens in food.

  31. How many days will it take for the cheque to clear? https://asianwhiteskin.com/stmap_15nrpill.html?levitra.amoxil.capoten.himplasia ciprofloxacina sandoz 500 mg Fred Umane, president of the New York City Board of Elections, told Capital that Thompson was using the board as scapegoat. “He had to blame somebody, so he blamed us," Umane said in a brief telephone interview. Overall, he said the of the board’s election day performance and vote-counting process: “I don’t think we did so badly."